Course Project: Development and Analysis of Two Mini Case Studies
Objectives | Guidelines | Grading Rubrics | Best Practices
Objectives Select, develop, and analyze two mini case studies. The purpose of this project is to identify
a successful strategy and compare and contrast it with an unsuccessful strategy, with the aim of identifying
critical success factors (CSFs). You may select two strategies developed in the same company or from entirely
different companies—or, indeed, different industries.
Case studies are used extensively in teaching business. Typically students perform an analysis on a case study
prepared by an author or the professor—in this instance, the student is the author of the cases. The case
study research strategy provides the opportunity to develop an in-depth understanding of an organization or
event—data can be collected from multiple sources (for example, company websites, interviews, or published
Please select two examples that reflect success and failure—collect data from multiple sources and develop two
mini case studies of 500 words in length. Perform a cross-case analysis by comparing and contrasting the case
studies on points of parity and points of difference. This should entail developing a framework, similar to
many of the frameworks presented in class (e.g., SWOT or Five Forces) and analyzing the key data in your case
studies. The analysis should be presented after your case studies and should be followed by a brief concluding
statement and references in APA format.
Guidelines Mini Case I: (Success): Sufficient length begins with general points and moves to a focus on
specifics, evidence of success, good quality content—relevant, accurate, and timely.
Mini Case II: (Failure): Sufficient length begins with general points and moves to a focus on specifics,
evidence of failure, good quality content—relevant, accurate, and timely.
Cross-Case Analysis: Once you have completed your cases you need to conduct a cross-case analysis. This
requires comparing the two cases to determine points of similarity and points of difference.
Research Skills: Each case uses four to six sources, and sources are cited in the text and at the end of the
case study in APA format.
Writing Skills: Ideas are communicated clearly in business English and using the appropriate business
terminology. Work should be prepared following the development of a rough draft, revision, editing, and
proofing to produce a final polished report.
A successful project will meet all of these requirements to earn a maximum of 200 points. At the conclusion of
this project it will be beneficial to compare what factors are selected by your peers. Are there patterns
• Week 1: Select company strategies, read supporting documents in Doc Sharing.
• Weeks 2–7: Research and prepare rough draft and analysis, followed by revision, editing, and proofing
• Week 8: Submit Final Report.
Category Points % Description
Mini Case I: Success 40 20% A quality paper will meet or exceed 500 words.
Mini Case II: Failure 40 20% A quality paper will meet or exceed 500 words.
Cross-Case Analysis 40 20% Includes framework and critical success factors.
Research Skills 40 20% Based on accurate, relevant, and timely sources.
Writing Skills 40 20% Business English, grammatically correct, error free, APA format.
Total 200 100% A quality paper will meet or exceed all of the above requirements.
The Process for Developing a Case Study and Cross-Case Analysis
• Generate topic ideas (brainstorm – use your experience – your interests – career oriented choices).
• Develop initial ideas (explore the Internet – library data bases).
• Select a topic (find the best fit between assignment and information/interest/experience obtained).
• Develop a research question/set of questions – e.g. Why did this strategy succeed? (answering this
question this will guide data collection and helps interpret results).
• Data collection and analysis:
o Decide on suitable sources and means to access these sources
o Conduct interviews/observations, if appropriate
o Collect published sources and record publication details (use APA format)
o Review data and determine gaps that need to be filled
o Determine case study structure (chronological or organized around key events/issues)
o Interpret data in relation to the initial research question
• Develop an outline – Say what you are going to say – Say it – Say you have said it (i.e. Introduction
– Main body – Summary and conclusion).
• Develop a rough draft, revise, edit and proof – this is critical to producing a good quality document.
• A good case study should be:
o Consider alternative perspectives
o Display sufficient evidence
o Be written in an engaging manner
Once you have completed your cases you need to conduct a cross-case analysis. This requires comparing the two
cases (or more) to determine point of similarity and points of difference. The objective is to determine the
critical success factors (CSFs). What are the key factors that led to success? Understanding success also
involves studying failure.
The following framework might be helpful. You should identify factors for comparison based on the
characteristics of your own cases. Such factors might be charismatic leadership, global growth, effective
value chain network.
The CSFs are based on your judgment of the evidence you have collected, and should emerge as you work through
this framework. What are the key factors that have led to success. It will be beneficial to compare what
factors are selected by your peers. Are there patterns here?
You can present your analysis in your report as a figure, but remember to introduce it and comment on what it
means and present your CSFs in the text. Remember to number your figure and give it a title, e.g. Figure 1:
Cross-Case Analysis, see below:
Figure 1: Cross-Case Analysis
Success: Company X Failures: Company Y Critical Success Factors
• • •
• • •
• • •
• • •
Delivering a high-quality product at a reasonable price is not enough anymore.
That’s why we have developed 5 beneficial guarantees that will make your experience with our service enjoyable, easy, and safe.
You have to be 100% sure of the quality of your product to give a money-back guarantee. This describes us perfectly. Make sure that this guarantee is totally transparent.Read more
Each paper is composed from scratch, according to your instructions. It is then checked by our plagiarism-detection software. There is no gap where plagiarism could squeeze in.Read more
Thanks to our free revisions, there is no way for you to be unsatisfied. We will work on your paper until you are completely happy with the result.Read more
Your email is safe, as we store it according to international data protection rules. Your bank details are secure, as we use only reliable payment systems.Read more
By sending us your money, you buy the service we provide. Check out our terms and conditions if you prefer business talks to be laid out in official language.Read more